Super skinny! - Boulder Denim Canadiana Athletic Fit - Men's

I purchased the athetic fit boulder denim jeans directly from the manufacturers website. I wear a size 32x34 and it was recommended to size down 1 size so I did and got the 31x34 and man we’re they were tight!!! I’m not a super skinny guy but I’m not fat Im 6ft1 and float around 187-195 lbs “athletic build” decent muscle mass. broad shouldered. I don’t have a gut of any kind. Awesome jeans but “athletic fit” no, if anything they were skinnier than my 511 Levi’s and I fit in those fine If anything size up one in the waist they fit like leggings and the stretch is the only reason it fit in the waist. I’m sure it’s a great product when sized correctly and I wanted to like them so bad but just couldn’t I still have them and haven’t returned them because I moved shortly after purchasing them and don’t have the original shipping info anymore and I’m probably out of the return window by now.