These did exactly what they needed to. They were easy to get on and they stayed on. I got these because I wear trail runners and the gaiter's loop under the shoe is thin -- I was worried gaiters with a thicker loop would stick out through the tread. However, because of this I fear breakage of the loop over time. I'll probably buy backup loops for this eventuality.
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.