The pluses:
Deep pockets
Nice length to stop wind from creeping in below
Very warm chest, stomach and back area
Good hood
The bad:
Arms are not warm enough (this alone prevents 5 stars)
The jacket feels like an ultra-fantastic down vest married to the somewhat anemic sleeves of a down sweater. When the wind blows, I feel it in the arms (which are not especially padded, and are not box construction). Next version perhaps Rab can up the ante on the arms a bit? That would make it a fantastic 5 star winter jacket.
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.