Had a pair of the former Mansalu gaiters. Much preferred the buckle boot strap as you could cinch the gaiter down for a tight seal. You could also slip the gaiter on before putting your boot on without opening the front velcro. The velcro boot strap prevents both of these. Also, the stretch watergate fabric has a thin inner scrim that is all there is between it and your boot. Wore it off afte
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.