Bought 2 of these for my family of 5. Camped one night and so far very happy. Very easy to setup, roomy, great ventilation. Quality components throughout. The "jakes' foot" pole and fly attachment system is awesome. Untested in wind, but has a number of tie down points. Performance of the reduced fly in rain... will have to trust the design team at this point in time, but can't see why it won't work fine.
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.